Just what is the difference between these two reds powders? I am comparing Red Tonik vs Organifi Red Juice to see which of these reds superfood supplements is the best for ingredients, price, and benefits.
Red Tonik is one of the newer reds powders available in today’s market. What it lacks in longevity, however, it more than makes up for in transparency.
You’d be hard-pressed to find a reds powder with a more detailed ingredient list than this! (Feel free to read the standalone Red Tonik Review here.)
Organifi’s Red Juice Powder, on the other might, is one of the most popular products made by Organifi. We’ve also reviewed their Green Juice, just FYI!
But in this review, we’ll be bringing together the best of both worlds — or at least both brands — by comparing Supergreen Tonik with Organifi’s take on a reds powder.
What to Look For In Reds Powders
Reds powders get their namesake color from beets, berries, and other red-hued fruits and veggies.
They’re typically designed to increase the body’s production of nitric oxide, resulting in better athletic performance, sexual performance, athletic recovery, cognitive function, and more. (Source)
Reds powders vary from greens powders in several ways.
While reds powders are comprised of beets and berries, their green counterparts are often heavier in veggies.
What Is Red Tonik?
Red Tonik is a brand new reds powder comprised of 13 organic, raw ingredients.
Among the highlights are nootropics, superfoods, and adaptogens.
Red Tonik’s Pros and Cons
Pros
- Each ingredient is present at its therapeutically-effective dose
- Third-party lab-tested and made in a cGMP facility
- Each ingredient is accurately, transparently listed
- Industry-leading 1-year money-back guarantee
- Keto-friendly, paleo-friendly, vegan-friendly
Cons
- Too new to the market to have lots of product reviews
- Slightly pricer than the average reds powder
Use code: RT11 for 11% Off
Full disclosure:
I developed Red Tonik with a US manufacturer after realizing how common shady marketing tactics are in this industry.
Unlike most other reds products, which hide their true contents behind the overuse of proprietary blends, Red Tonik fully discloses every one of its active ingredients.
What Is Organifi Red Juice?
Organifi’s Red Juice is a “Tart-Sweet” reds powder that purports to be the “HOTTEST Fat Melting” and “Skin-Firming Superfood” in the world.
Organifi’s website is also bright and hopeful.
The brand aims to raise the standards of the nutraceutical industry, claiming that its products have been extensively researched — and even clinically tested! We’ll examine these claims a little later.
Organifi Red Juice Pros and Cons
Pros
- Keto-friendly, paleo-friendly, and vegan-friendly
- Third-party lab-tested and cGMP-friendly
- Includes a 60-day money-back guarantee
Cons
- Lack of ingredient disclosure
- Unproven claims
- Chalky texture
Red Tonik vs. Organifi: Ingredients Overview
Red Tonik Ingredients List
Red Tonik is made in a cGMP facility and tested by independent 3rd-party labs.
That means they’re verifiably free from toxins and heavy metals.
Red Tonik’s ingredients can be divided into three primary categories:
Beetroot (1.5 grams)
Beetroot may improve circulation and regulate blood pressure.
It’s incredible for athletic performance, too. Shown to help regulate circulation and blood pressure.
Its ability to naturally increase NO2 levels means it may improve energy and stamina, too.
Cordyceps Mycelium Extract (1 gram)
Cordyceps are natural adaptogens that have general adaptogenic effects.
They may boost both cognitive function and athletic performance.
Tumeric Root Extract (500mg)
Turmeric is one of the natural world’s most potent antioxidant sources.
Studies show that turmeric’s most active ingredient, curcumin, may ‘quench’ harmful free radicals and other oxidized molecules.
Ginger Root Extract (100mg)
Ginger is anti-oxidant, anti-inflammatory, and even anti-parasite.
Plus it’s super energizing! (Source)
Grape Seed Extract (200mg)
Grapeseed extract is another natural antioxidant.
Trans-Reservatrol (150mg)
Best known for its presence in red wine, resveratrol may be protective against diabetes and other degenerative disorders.
Tart Cherry Fruit Powder (500mg)
Tart cherry extract may simultaneously reduce inflammation and improve metabolic health, making it a boon for those who are always on the go.
Cranberry Fruit Extract (500mg)
Cranberry fruit extract may improve cardiovascular health by regulating blood pressure and cholesterol.
Pomegranate Fruit Powder (250mg)
Pomegranate is rich in a variety of antioxidants, including polyphenols.
Goji fruit powder (250mg)
Goji berry powder is a true superfood.
It’s rich in antioxidants, flavonoids, and vitamin A.
Blueberry Fruit Powder (150mg)
Rich in anthocyanins and other antioxidants, allowing them to improve mental, physical, and cognitive health.
Raspberry Fruit Powder (100mg)
Rich in antioxidants, raspberries may protect bone and skin cells from degeneration.
Strawberry Fruit Powder (100mg)
Strawberry fruit powder is also — surprise — high in antioxidants and anti-inflammatories.
Here is the full ingredient label (with no proprietary blends in sight!):
Check out how Red Tonik compares to other red superfood supplements:
Red Juice Ingredients List
Red Juice contains three proprietary blends: an antioxidant berry blend, an endurance blend, and a metabolic-boosting blend.
It also contains several other ingredients.
Antioxidant Berry Blend (2100mg)
- Organic Pomegranate Powder Juice
- Organic Blueberry Juice Powder
- Organic Cranberry Powder
- Organic Strawberry
- Organic Raspberry
Endurance Blend (3050mg)
- Organic Reishi Mushroom Extract
- Organic Beet Root Powder
- Organic Cordyceps
Metabolic Boosting Blend (1300mg)
- Organic Acai Juice Powder
- Organic Siberian Ginseng
- Organic Rhodiola
Other Ingredients
- Monk Fruit Extract Flavor
- Organic Artichoke Inulin
- Natural Berry Flavor
- Malic Acid
Here is the Organifi Red Juice full ingredient label:
Related: Check out my comparison between Organifi Green Juice and Red Juice if you're confused which brand is best.
Red Tonik vs. Organifi Red Juice: Top Benefits
Red Tonik Top Benefits
Red Tonik’s therapeutically-dosed active ingredients mean you can be fairly confident of its health benefits.
Red Tonik may:
- Improve your tolerance to stress and/or environmental toxins
- Improve cardiovascular health and nitric oxide production
- Improve antioxidant status and antioxidant production
- Improve your overall energy levels
- Improve your innate immunity
- Improve athletic performance (Source)
Red Juice Top Benefits
Organifi’s Red Juice also has important health benefits — in theory, at least.
The problem is that we don’t know exactly how much of anything is contained in Red Juice.
How many mg of pomegranate extract are present? How many mg of cordyceps of reishi? How much strawberry extract?
How much acai?
These ingredients have clinically-demonstrated benefits, but only if they’re taken at the appropriate dose.
I simply can’t know if any of the ingredients in Red Juice are present at the right doses, so I can’t have any certainty of its benefits.
Red Tonik vs. Organifi Red Juice: How Do They Taste?
Taste can be a hit-or-miss thing regarding reds powders, and neither Red Tonik nor Red Juice is an exception.
Red Tonik Taste
I spent plenty of time researching and experimenting with various flavor blends when making Red Tonik.
Most of our customers enjoy mixing it with water, but if you don’t like the cranberry taste, you can always combine it with a favorite juice or smoothie recipe.
Red Juice Taste
Red Juice has a tart, sweet taste that some customers enjoy…others, not so much.
Red Tonik vs. Organifi Red Juice: Where to Buy
You can buy Red Tonik on their website here, and Organifi on their website here and on Amazon here.
Red Tonik vs. Organifi Red Juice: Are They Reasonably Priced?
That depends on what you consider reasonable.
Reds powders tend to be slightly more expensive than other supplements, in large part because they’re a newer type of wellness product.
Red Tonik Pricing and Refund Policy
Red Tonik falls slightly on the pricy side due to the clinically proven dosages in the formula.
- $77 per 30 days / $2.56 per serving
- $197 per 90 days / $2.18 per serving
- $337 per 180 days / $1.85 per serving
Red Tonik may not be cheap, but on the bright side, it possesses what’s probably the industry’s return policy: a one-year money-back guarantee.
If you’re not fully happy with Red Tonik, feel free to return it within that timeframe for a full refund.
Red Juice Pricing and Refund Policy
Red Juice is slightly cheaper than Red Tonik when buying only 1-2 tubs, Red Tonik is cheaper when buying in bulk.
- $69.95 USD per 30 days / $2.33 per serving
- $178.38 USD per 90 days / $1.98 per serving
Organifi has a 60-day no-questions-asked, money-back guarantee, which also goes above and beyond industry standards.
What Customers Say About Red Tonik and Organifi
Red Tonik Top Reviews
Red Tonik doesn’t have many customer reviews yet, but the reviews it does have are pretty promising!
Andy says Red Tonik has improved his fitness routine:
“This is a game changer for my health & fitness.”
Sarah likes the taste:
The tastiest reds powder I have tried. Packed full of nutrients I am looking for in a supplement!
Meanwhile, Paul from the UK also loves the taste:
Love the colour, the taste. Awesome way to get your beets and berries in one glass!
Red Juice Top Reviews
On Amazon Red Juice has over 1,500 reviews. That’s a lot! The average review comes in at 4.3 out of 5 stars.
One customer says Red Juice contains too much sugar:
It's OK but I'd prefer half the amount of sugar. If they could increase their scale and lower the price, I could see this in almost every home.
Another describes nice effects but a not-so-nice texture:
“This product gives me the energy I need. I mix it in my water bottle and drink it throughout the day. (It does have some grittiness to it, but that is due to the ingredients.)”
Last but not least, one customer gives raving reviews and says Red Juice was a worthy purchase:
I ordered the sunrise to sunset kit which is the green, red, and gold juices. They all taste delicious. My favorite is the red juice because I love the afternoon pick me up that it delivers without any caffeine.
I am very sensitive to caffeine and am happy for this alternative. I am committed to this journey of better health and wellness and am using the Organifi system to get there. I did a lot of research before buying the product and am very pleased after trying for myself.
In the morning I reset with the green juice, in the afternoon energize with the red and then in the evening relax with the gold. Don't wait another minute, give it a try and you won't be disappointed.
Red Tonik vs. Organifi Red Juice: My Verdict
While both Red Tonik and Red Juice are reds powders, Red Tonik shines in the very same area where Red Juice is lacking: transparency.
This difference becomes readily apparent when comparing Organifi to Red Tonik, or SuperGreen Tonik.
It could be that none of Red Juice’s active ingredients are dosed appropriately….but there’s no way to know for sure. Personally, I’m not going to spend $30-60+ a month on a product I’m uncertain about. For now, Red Tonik is a far better choice!
LifeHacker Guy Reds Recommendation
I designed Red Tonik after trying over 80 superfood supplements and noticing just how common proprietary blends and other shady marketing were.
Most super reds supplements are disappointing.
In 2022 I created my own super reds brand that ticks every single box of what I look for in a super reds supplement:
- No hidden ingredient amounts - we have full disclosure labelling, so you know EXACTLY whats inside
- Ingredient amounts that make a difference - we include the minimum effective amounts supported by research, and most of the time, MORE
- Ingredients that help cardiovascular health, boost antioxidant intake and help recovery - making for a much more productive and happy lifestyle
No more worrying about ineffective ingredients or too low dosages. I finally have a product I KNOW does the job it’s made to do.
I use it every day and, after years of battling Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS), I now have my energy (and my life!) back.
The good news? I made my brand available to the public so you can see and feel the difference for yourself.